Design 
  Community 
  Architecture 
  Discussion 
 

Message - Re: Recreate architects' works - your opinion?

    Responses | Architecture Forum | Architecture Students | Architecture Scrapbook | ArchitectureWeek    
   

Posted by  Rog the Dodge on February 20, 2003 at 11:02:01:

In Reply to:  Re: Recreate architects' works - your opinion? posted by Eric Yukins on February 20, 2003 at 10:06:36:

Two Charles Rennie Mackintosh buildings have been created in Scotland since the 1990s, both from sketches or competition drawings: neither was constructed in his lifetime.

The first is the Artist's Country Cottage which was built just south of Inverness. Having used the CRM sketch as a student analysis programme I know that the original plans and elevations don't fit, so whoever put this thing up in the 1990s had to do a considerable amount of guesswork and interpretation on their own account.

The second is CRM's entry for the Haus fur Eines Kunstfreundes competition which was erected on a site in Glasgow with my former professor, Andy Macmillan, who should have known better, in charge. Again a considerable amount of guesswork was involved.

We know that CRM changed his designs as they evolved on site. Here we have two building erected from incomplete plans adapted by a third party and missing CRM's genius of on-site adaptation. So what do we think we're getting. Yep! It's a mule and a camel.

By the way the Larkin is of particular significance in FLW's oeuvre, so dont write it off too quickly. But, certainly don't attempt to reconstruct it.

 
 
ArchitectureWeek     Search     Buildings     Architects     Types     Places     Pix     Free 3D Models     Store     Library

Search GreatBuildings.com by name of Building, Architect, or Place:   
Examples:  "Fallingwater",  "Wright",  "Paris"           Advanced Search

Responses:




Post a Response -

Name:
E-Mail:

Subject:


This is an archive page. Please post continuing discussion to the new Architecture Forums.

To post successfully to the new membership-based DesignCommunity Forums:

    1) Go to the new forums area.
    2) Register with a valid email address.
    3) Receive and respond to the confirmation email.
    4) Then login to the new forum system.



 

Special thanks to our Sustaining Subscribers including BuilderSpace.com .

Home | Great Buildings | CAD Outpost | DesignWorkshop | Free 3D | Gallery | Search | ArchitectureWeek
This document is provided for on-line viewing only. /discussion/25644.html